The Philadelphia Phillies’ disappointing 2026 season is over, and the organization now faces an offseason filled with difficult decisions. A Wild Card Series exit was never the objective for a team built to compete for a championship, so the early part of the offseason will inevitably focus on which players should return and which ones should be allowed to leave.
The Phillies are entering a potentially important transition period. Several veterans are approaching free agency, while other expensive contracts continue to limit how dramatically president of baseball operations Dave Dombrowski can reshape the roster. Still, Philadelphia is expected to have significant financial flexibility this winter, with roughly $93 million potentially coming off the books when expiring contracts and other obligations are taken into account.
That does not mean all of that money will become available for new players. Some of the expiring contracts could be replaced by new deals with the same players, while Philadelphia’s existing commitments to Bryce Harper, Kyle Schwarber, Trea Turner and Aaron Nola will continue to consume a substantial portion of the payroll. Nevertheless, the 2027 Phillies could look considerably different from the club that opened the 2026 season.
Among the most important decisions are those involving Alec Bohm, Luis Arraez, Edmundo Sosa, Adolis García, Tim Mayza, José Alvarado and Brooks Raley.
Alec Bohm — 20% chance to return
Bohm’s future may be one of the most fascinating decisions facing the Phillies.
His final moment with Philadelphia was fittingly memorable. During Game 2 of the Wild Card Series against Atlanta, Bohm delivered a dramatic home run in extra innings, giving the Phillies a crucial victory and temporarily extending their postseason hopes.
But despite that moment, his overall tenure in Philadelphia has never fully matched expectations.
Bohm was selected third overall in the 2018 MLB Draft and immediately showed why the Phillies were so excited about his potential. As a rookie, he produced a .338/.400/.481 slash line, establishing expectations that he could eventually become one of the organization’s premier offensive players.
He never consistently reached that level again.
His 2026 season was particularly uneven. Bohm struggled badly during the first half, batting only .215. However, his second-half turnaround offered a reminder of the player Philadelphia once believed it was drafting. He hit .298/.369/.425 after the All-Star break and finished the season playing much better than he started it.
Still, the projection is that Bohm is more likely to leave than remain.
A change of scenery could benefit both sides. Bohm could potentially flourish in a less demanding environment, while Philadelphia could use his departure to create room for a different type of player.
Prediction: 20% chance he re-signs, 80% chance he leaves.
Luis Arraez — 30% chance to return
Arraez was supposed to be one of the additions that significantly changed the Phillies’ offensive profile.
Philadelphia’s lineup has plenty of power, but it also features several hitters who strike out frequently. Arraez was brought in partly because of his elite contact ability and reputation as one of baseball’s best pure hitters.
Unfortunately, his first season with Philadelphia did not live up to expectations.
He struggled to reproduce the offensive consistency that made him so valuable earlier in his career and was also dealing with an injury that prevented him from contributing during the postseason.
Nevertheless, the Phillies still have a legitimate need for the type of hitter Arraez represents.
Retaining him would create some roster complications. His presence could force Philadelphia to move Bryson Stott away from second base, although Stott demonstrated late in the season that he could handle third base adequately.
The biggest factor could ultimately be Arraez’s market.
If other teams offer him a significant contract, Philadelphia may allow him to leave. But if his market develops slowly and his price drops, the Phillies could potentially bring him back on a shorter or cheaper deal.
Prediction: 30% chance he re-signs, 70% chance he leaves.
Edmundo Sosa — 40% chance to return
Sosa might be one of the most valuable players on the free-agent list despite not being an everyday starter.
Since arriving in Philadelphia in the 2022 trade with St. Louis, Sosa has established himself as one of the team’s most dependable utility players. His value goes beyond his offensive numbers because of his ability to play multiple positions.
That versatility makes the Phillies’ entire roster easier to manage.
Sosa can give starters days off without forcing Philadelphia to dramatically weaken its defense. He can also step into different positions when injuries occur, which is an especially valuable skill over a 162-game season.
The problem is that Sosa may have earned the right to become a regular starter somewhere else.
If he is willing to continue playing a utility role in Philadelphia, there is a realistic path toward a reunion. But if another club offers him a starting job, the Phillies may have little opportunity to match that offer because they do not currently have an obvious everyday position available for him.
Prediction: 40% chance he re-signs, 60% chance he leaves.
Adolis García — 5% chance to return
García’s 2026 season was one of the clearest disappointments among Philadelphia’s free-agent additions.
The Phillies once again attempted to use a platoon-style approach in the corner outfield, but the experiment failed to produce the desired results.
García could theoretically return as an inexpensive bench option, particularly if his market collapses.
However, that appears unlikely.
The more realistic outcome is that García joins another organization where he can compete for a starting position and attempt to rebuild his value.
For Philadelphia, moving on would create an opportunity to pursue an outfielder who better fits the club’s long-term plans.
Prediction: 5% chance he re-signs, 95% chance he leaves.
Tim Mayza — 60% chance to return
Mayza is arguably the free agent the Phillies have the strongest incentive to retain.
At age 34, Mayza put together a season that could earn him consideration for down-ballot Comeback Player of the Year votes. More importantly, Philadelphia’s coaching staff played a significant role in helping him rediscover his effectiveness.
The transformation of his sinker became one of the biggest stories of his season. Under pitching coach Caleb Cotham and the Phillies’ pitching-development system, Mayza developed into one of the more dependable arms in the bullpen.
That matters enormously for Philadelphia.
The Phillies desperately need reliable relief pitching after another season in which the bullpen created problems. Bringing back a pitcher who already knows the coaching staff and has demonstrated that he can succeed in the team’s system would be a logical move.
The fact that Mayza should not command an enormous contract also improves the chances of a reunion.
Prediction: 60% chance he re-signs, 40% chance he leaves.
José Alvarado — 1% chance to return
Alvarado’s Philadelphia future appears almost completely finished.
The Phillies’ decision to exercise his $9 million club option for 2026 was already viewed as a gamble following his PED suspension in 2025. Unfortunately, the experiment did not produce the hoped-for comeback.
Instead, Alvarado endured the worst season of his decade-long major-league career.
Command problems became a major issue, and Philadelphia will likely search for alternative left-handed bullpen options this offseason.
Given his struggles and the organization’s apparent need for more dependable relief pitching, a return appears extremely unlikely.
Prediction: 1% chance he re-signs, 99% chance he leaves.
Brooks Raley — 5% chance to return
Raley’s short Philadelphia tenure was another major disappointment.
The Phillies acquired him at the trade deadline hoping he would stabilize the bullpen, but his performance never reached the level the organization expected.
In only 16 appearances, Raley was responsible for three blown saves and two losses.
That is particularly damaging when considering the importance of his role and the fact that Philadelphia needed its deadline additions to strengthen the bullpen for the postseason.
Instead, Raley struggled to find consistency and became one of the least successful deadline additions.
His departure should therefore come as little surprise.
Prediction: 5% chance he re-signs, 95% chance he leaves.
Philadelphia could enter 2027 with a noticeably different roster
The Phillies’ free-agent decisions will not happen in isolation.
The organization still has major money committed to its established stars, meaning Dombrowski cannot simply tear the roster apart and start again. Harper, Schwarber, Turner and Nola remain central pieces of the franchise.
But the amount of money potentially coming off the books gives Philadelphia some room to maneuver.
The bigger question is how aggressively the Phillies choose to use that flexibility.
After another postseason disappointment, simply replacing departing players with similar pieces may not be enough. The organization needs to identify why this roster continues to struggle when the stakes become highest and determine whether certain positions need significant upgrades.
Bohm’s potential departure could create an opening for a different type of infielder. Arraez could potentially return if his market falls. Sosa’s versatility would be useful, while Mayza’s bullpen resurgence makes him one of the more logical free agents to retain.
Meanwhile, García, Alvarado and Raley appear increasingly likely to move on.
The result could be a Phillies team that retains its superstar core but looks noticeably different around it.
The offseason could reshape the Phillies’ championship window
Philadelphia’s championship window remains open, but the clock is moving.
The organization has invested heavily in its veteran core, and another early postseason exit only increases the pressure to get the supporting cast right.
The seven impending free agents therefore represent more than simple roster transactions. Each decision will help determine whether the Phillies make another attempt with essentially the same formula or begin gradually changing the construction of the team.
The most likely outcome is somewhere in between.
Philadelphia is unlikely to completely overhaul the roster, but several familiar faces could disappear before Opening Day 2027. Bohm, Arraez and Sosa all have legitimate reasons to return, while Mayza appears to be the most logical bullpen priority. García, Alvarado and Raley, meanwhile, are much more likely to move on.
After a season that ended well short of the organization’s expectations, those decisions could become the first major steps toward determining whether the Phillies can finally turn their talented roster into another deep October run.
Leave a Reply