The St. Louis Cardinals may have entered the 2026 season with modest expectations, but their surprisingly competitive campaign has created a much more complicated question heading into 2027: How good should this team actually be expected to become?
That may be the biggest challenge facing the organization this offseason. The Cardinals finished 2026 with a 77-85 record, a result that fell short of a winning season but still exceeded many of the expectations surrounding a young roster entering a rebuilding phase. The team showed enough progress to excite fans, but not enough consistency to suggest that the rebuilding process is complete.
That creates an unusual situation for St. Louis. The Cardinals have reason to believe the foundation is improving, yet the front office must resist allowing one encouraging season to accelerate the rebuild prematurely.
A 2026 Season That Exceeded Expectations
For much of the 2026 campaign, the Cardinals gave their supporters plenty of reasons to be optimistic. A roster filled with young players was given opportunities to establish themselves, and several of those players responded with performances that changed the perception of the organization’s future.
Jordan Walker was one of the biggest positive developments. After enduring considerable struggles previously, Walker produced a remarkable comeback season and even captured an unexpected Home Run Derby victory, providing one of the most memorable moments of the Cardinals’ year.
JJ Wetherholt also strengthened his case as an important part of the organization’s future. His defensive development at second base stood out, while his offensive potential suggested that he could become a significant two-way contributor as he gains more experience.
Alec Burleson was another major success story. He developed into a productive run producer and finished the season leading the league in RBI, giving St. Louis an offensive weapon that was not necessarily expected to reach that level.
Then came Joshua Baez, who immediately captured attention with one of the most explosive debuts imaginable. His three-home-run introduction against the Cubs provided another glimpse of the young talent available to the organization.
Late in the season, Leo Bernal’s arrival added another layer of excitement. His emergence behind the plate gave many Cardinals fans hope that the organization may have found another long-term piece at catcher.
Taken together, those developments helped explain why the fan base viewed the 2026 season relatively positively despite the losing record.
Fans Were More Positive Than the Record Suggests
A post-season fan poll reflected that sentiment. A majority of voters gave the Cardinals a B grade for their 2026 campaign, while only a small percentage rated the season below a C.
That reaction is significant because the Cardinals were never expected to be a finished product.
The roster was designed partly to evaluate young players and determine which ones could become part of the next competitive St. Louis team. In that context, a 77-85 record was not necessarily viewed as a failure.
But there were also enough warning signs to prevent the organization from becoming overly optimistic.
Nolan Gorman took a step backward and could potentially be headed toward an offseason change. Matthew Liberatore struggled to establish himself consistently. Most concerning, the bullpen became a major problem during the second half of the season.
Even Walker’s impressive campaign came with some caution. His late-season swing decisions began to resemble some of the issues that had affected him previously, leaving the organization with another question to answer during the offseason.
The Cardinals therefore finished 2026 in an interesting middle ground: better than many expected, but still clearly in need of significant improvement.
Chaim Bloom Wants the Rebuild to Stay on Track
That uncertainty was reflected in comments from president of baseball operations Chaim Bloom following the season.
Bloom warned that the team’s encouraging stretch during the summer could create unrealistic expectations. As the Cardinals began winning more games, some fans started believing the rebuild was progressing faster than originally anticipated.
Bloom’s message was essentially that the organization cannot allow a surprisingly good stretch to change the overall strategy.
That may become one of the most important themes of the Cardinals’ offseason.
The front office must decide how aggressively to improve the Major League roster while continuing to strengthen the farm system. Those two objectives do not necessarily conflict, but finding the right balance will be crucial.
If St. Louis spends heavily or trades away valuable prospects simply to chase a few additional wins in 2027, it could undermine the longer-term rebuilding plan. On the other hand, refusing to make meaningful Major League additions could frustrate fans who believe the young roster has already developed enough to compete for a winning record.
The Bullpen Remains a Major Concern
Among the most obvious areas for improvement is the bullpen.
A large portion of the Cardinals fan base identified relief pitching as the organization’s top priority for 2027, and that concern is understandable after the bullpen’s second-half struggles.
St. Louis will need dependable pitchers capable of handling the middle innings while also finding reliable options for high-leverage situations. Adding several arms could make a major difference without requiring the organization to abandon its rebuilding philosophy.
The Cardinals also have roster questions at third base and center field.
One possible solution could involve using the organization’s catching depth as a trade asset. St. Louis has several players who could potentially attract interest from other teams, giving Bloom an opportunity to address another weakness without sacrificing the organization’s most valuable prospects.
Alec Burleson Presents Another Major Decision
Perhaps one of the most fascinating decisions concerns Burleson.
The Cardinals still have two years of control remaining over the outfielder, including two more seasons of salary arbitration. After his breakout production in 2026, St. Louis must decide whether he is a core player worth extending or an asset whose trade value may never be higher.
Burleson has indicated that he is open to discussing an extension, putting the ball in the organization’s court.
A long-term deal would give the Cardinals another established piece around which to build their next competitive roster. Trading him, meanwhile, could bring back young talent or address another weakness if the front office believes his value has peaked.
That decision could provide an important indication of how quickly Bloom believes the Cardinals are ready to transition from rebuilding toward competing.
Rotation Decisions Could Shape 2027
The starting rotation also remains unsettled.
The expectation is that Liberatore will receive another opportunity as a starter in 2027. Andre Pallante, Michael McGreevy and Kyle Leahy should also be considered important pieces of the rotation.
Leahy’s workload will be worth monitoring after he was limited somewhat during the 2026 campaign. If the Cardinals intend to compete, they will need more innings from their young pitchers while also protecting them from overuse.
Adding one or two reliable starters could therefore be extremely valuable.
There is also a strategic question surrounding Liberatore. Rather than automatically committing him to a rotation role, St. Louis could potentially use him in the middle innings if stronger starting options are acquired.
However, the organization’s comments suggest that Liberatore is likely to receive another opportunity to establish himself as a starter.
The Biggest Question: Are the Cardinals Ready to Win?
Ultimately, the Cardinals’ biggest 2027 challenge may not be a specific position or player.
It may be managing expectations.
Fans saw enough encouraging developments in 2026 to believe that the team can take another step forward. The young core is beginning to take shape, and several players have demonstrated that they can contribute at the Major League level.
But the Cardinals are not yet a finished contender.
The front office must determine how much outside help is appropriate while continuing to develop the players already inside the organization. Free-agent signings, trades and prospect development will all play roles, but the timing and scale of those moves could determine whether St. Louis accelerates its rebuild or remains patient.
A .500 season may now feel like a reasonable expectation to many fans. Some may even expect the Cardinals to push beyond that mark after the progress shown in 2026.
The bigger question is whether Bloom and the rest of the front office share that expectation.
The answer will not come only from what the organization says during the offseason. It will be revealed by what St. Louis actually does before Spring Training 2027.
The Cardinals have already surprised their supporters once.
Now they must decide whether 2026 was the beginning of a genuine turnaround—or simply a promising step in a rebuild that still has a long way to go.
Leave a Reply