Former New York Mets general manager Zack Scott has openly acknowledged that trading Pete Crow-Armstrong to the Chicago Cubs remains one of the biggest regrets of his baseball career, admitting that the pressure to make a blockbuster move during a playoff race caused him to abandon the disciplined decision-making that had long guided his front-office philosophy.
Five years after the deal reshaped the futures of both franchises, Crow-Armstrong has emerged as one of Major League Baseball’s brightest young stars. The Cubs outfielder is heading to his second consecutive All-Star Game, establishing himself as an elite two-way player with Gold Glove-caliber defense, game-changing speed, and the potential to become one of baseball’s premier 30-home run, 30-stolen base threats.
Meanwhile, the trade continues to haunt the Mets.
Scott recently reflected on the controversial transaction that sent the highly regarded prospect—who was recovering from injury at the time—to Chicago in exchange for veteran infielder Javier Báez and right-handed pitcher Trevor Williams during the 2021 trade deadline.
Although the move was designed to strengthen New York’s playoff push, Scott admitted he allowed the urgency of competing for a postseason berth to outweigh his usual commitment to protecting the organization’s long-term future.
In a candid statement, Scott acknowledged that while many believe he simply misjudged Crow-Armstrong’s talent, the larger mistake was allowing the pressure to “do something big” during a pennant race to influence his decision.
The admission represents one of the clearest acknowledgments from a former executive about the dangers of sacrificing elite prospects for short-term gains.
At the time of the trade, the Mets believed Báez could provide the offensive spark needed to secure a postseason berth. The former Cubs star initially delivered, batting .299 with a .371 on-base percentage and a .515 slugging percentage after arriving in New York, injecting life into the lineup during the closing months of the season.
However, the optimism quickly faded.
Báez’s tenure with the Mets became overshadowed by the highly publicized “thumbs down” controversy involving fans, and New York collapsed down the stretch. After entering August in playoff contention, the Mets stumbled to a disappointing 20-37 finish, ultimately missing the postseason altogether.
The gamble proved even more costly when Báez departed in free agency after the season, signing a long-term contract with the Detroit Tigers, leaving New York with little lasting value from the blockbuster deal.
Crow-Armstrong, on the other hand, has blossomed into the franchise cornerstone the Cubs envisioned when they acquired him.
Now one of baseball’s most exciting young players, the dynamic center fielder has become a cornerstone of Chicago’s rebuilding success. His elite defense, explosive athleticism, improving offensive production, and ability to impact games on both sides of the ball have transformed him into one of the National League’s premier talents and a player many believe could anchor the Cubs for years to come.
Scott’s comments have also reignited debate over how contenders should approach the trade deadline, particularly as the Cubs prepare for another crucial summer under president of baseball operations Jed Hoyer.
Chicago finds itself in a difficult position entering the second half of the 2026 season. While the Cubs remain in the playoff hunt, injuries have severely weakened their starting rotation, prompting many fans to call for an aggressive pursuit of frontline starters such as Tarik Skubal or Joe Ryan.
Acquiring pitchers of that caliber, however, would almost certainly require Chicago to part with top prospects—raising concerns about repeating the type of mistake Scott now regrets.
The Cubs possess one of baseball’s stronger farm systems, and several key roster decisions loom after the season. As a result, Hoyer must carefully balance the desire to strengthen the current roster with the responsibility of preserving the organization’s long-term championship window.
Scott’s experience serves as a powerful reminder of the risks associated with deadline deals. While aggressive trades can provide an immediate boost, they can also leave organizations regretting the loss of future stars if short-term success fails to materialize.
With Crow-Armstrong now emerging as one of baseball’s brightest young talents and the centerpiece of Chicago’s future, Scott’s honest reflection has become more than a confession—it has evolved into a cautionary tale for every executive weighing whether to sacrifice tomorrow in pursuit of today’s championship dreams.
Leave a Reply